« Financial literacy foundation donates $1 million to EEI, Inc. | Main | You gotta Levitt: S.E.C. chairman admits to not being able to read a prospectus »

December 03, 2010

Think twice before you ‘Like’: Social media are credit card companies’ newest weapon

Socialmedia
Better risk management: That was the biggest and hardest lesson learned by credit card companies during the credit crunch, which started in fall of 2008.  Ever since that frightening period—some call it 'The Great Recession’—consumers and businesses alike have experienced tighter risk management through closed accounts, reduced credit lines, higher interest rates, and more stringent guidelines for credit applicants. 

In an unprecedented effort to minimize their risk, credit card companies and banks have sought every possible resource at their disposal to capture and to store more information about customers—and that includes using social media. While many consumers understand that companies have access to their transaction histories and credit reports, most overlook the tremendous metadata available via social media companies like Facebook.  With the help of such new media, credit card companies have almost a 360 degree look at their customers. 

For example, a credit card company—or an insurance company, for that matter —does a search for profiles mentioning rock climbing.  They cross reference customer e-mail addresses with Facebook profiles.  Over 75,000 matches are returned.  One particular profile shows live pictures of a customer scaling K2, one the most difficult mountains in the world.  The customer has a rather high balance and a high tolerance for living on the edge.  Does the company cancel his account, considering he has a much higher likelihood of imminent death?  Perhaps it cancels the account and gives a lesser important reason like his debt-to-available-credit ratio being too high. 

Information about how credit card companies use data to assess risk—especially when ethics are questionable—is often revealed after the fact, when an employee leaks such information or it is deciphered by a discerning customer.  By then, the damage has been done; valuable information has been captured, aggregated, and stored in a database somewhere subject to the latest algorithm.  However, with the advent of social media and major partnerships, one can figure out current trends. 

One of Facebook’s first advertising customers was Chase in 2006. Here is an excerpt from The Facebook Effect, a recent bestseller that narrates the history and exponential growth of Facebook:

“Chase credit cards was an important pioneer.  Working with a small New York ad Agency called Noise Marketing, it created the Chase + 1 card, specially designed for college students and only available to Facebook users... A week after the program launched, 34,000 students had already joined the group, and Chase soon issued thousands of cards.“

In the same way, American Express has taken advantage of Facebook’s open social graph and API.  Its latest campaign, Small Business Saturday, is partially a public relations scheme to get users to subject themselves to increased data analysis.  Of course, American Express makes money through increased merchant fees by pushing such a campaign, but that’s not a bad thing per say.  In the end, the metadata is more valuable. (In a side note, when I saw the campaign show up in my News Feed on Facebook, I went to the web site to learn more.  A few days later, much to my surprise, the campaign was there in my 'Likes' box.  That was strange, especially since I didn’t press any 'Like' button.)

In conclusion, credit card companies are always one step ahead of the market and two steps ahead of the average consumer. They have to be, for that’s how they make money. Social media and its metadata enable credit card companies to get even further ahead.  Yes, social media are  awesome tools—I love them myself—but consumers must be smarter about exposing the details of their lives to companies that have a history of unscrupulous practices.  In short, think twice before you ‘Like’. 

Related Articles:

Beware: These stores could harm your credit! (Part II)

Good Morning America broadcasts my story to over four million

Beware: These stores could harm your credit!

Major paper runs my story on consumer profiling?

Amex Supports Shopping Day for Small Businesses with Promotions

 

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I love the way card issuer are using social media these days. They are all looking for ways to give us incentives to use their cards and I have nothing against that. I understand that there is the risk of getting people who lack self-restraint to overspend by making card use more attractive, but that is always a possibility and not a good enough reason to interfere.

You are too witty for me. If you 'Like' my site--I've got to put a button on the blog still--it most certainly will increase your credit score and industry awareness. =) Thanks for the comment, Tamara.

I went on a 'liking' spree a few weeks ago. So, I'm sure the credit card companies are having a field day with my information now.

So much info is readily available, that the Internet can be a blessing and a curse at the same time.

After reading this post, I'll be more prudent before 'liking' something, but it's sometimes hard to resist, when you get discounts for simply clicking the 'like' button.

On the other hand, are those discounts worth it in the long run, if it affects my credit score? Probably not.

Also, I just saw your interview on GMA. I'm late, yes, I know. Wow! I had no idea credit card companies could reduce your credit line based on where you choose to shop!

Very informative posts, Kevin. I'm going to have to 'like' your blog...or will that hurt my credit score. :-)

i think a lot of people have totally overlooked this. it will be interesting to see how this changes the industry. i think the problem is much biggger than we think it is. only time will tell.

Doh! They already got me. Thanks for sharing, Kevin. Keep up the good work. Can't wait to read what's next.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Follow up on Twitter!





About Me

Greetings! I’m Kevin D. Johnson, a business owner who has recently assumed the role of consumer advocate and internet activist. Atlanta, Georgia is my home.

My Story

Upon returning from my wonderful honeymoon in Jamaica in October 2008, I received what I thought was an ordinary American Express bill, but to my surprise it was a disappointing letter informing me that my credit line was reduced by about 65% for a highly suspicious and discriminatory reason. Considering my excellent credit score and pristine payment history, it just didn’t make sense. However, what does make sense are the unfair and insidious policies that I have uncovered when asking why. It is time to change them.

Good Morning America tells my story.

The Goal

I created this web site to document and share my challenging journey to change what is wrong, unfair, and unjust in the credit card industry. The ultimate goal of this web site is to inform consumers of ways to stand up for themselves against treacherous business practices and to educate consumers about how to improve their credit. Finally, I hope to encourage a more open dialogue with credit card companies about their policies–good and bad.

Success

I am proud to say that this blog's unyielding demand for change led to an important amendment in the final Credit CARD Act signed by President Obama on May 22, 2009. Despite this major accomplishment, there is still more work to be done.

View video of bill hearing in Maryland

Testifying at a bill hearing in Annapolis, Maryland

Speaking Engagements

In an effort to educate as many people as possible about financial management, especially about how to manage the current credit crisis, I have begun to speak around the country at colleges, universities, corporations, chamber of commerce meetings, congressional hearings, trade organization meetings, etc. Having acquired a wealth of information that will help to empower people and to improve their financial future, I feel that sharing this information is the least I can do to make a positive impact. For information on my availability for speaking opportunities, please send an e-mail to Jennifer Silverman at [email protected].


Speaking at a university

Disclaimer

All information provided on NewCreditRules.com is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute or substitute for professional financial advice. Information on NewCreditRules.com is subject to change without prior notice. Although every reasonable effort is made to present current and accurate information, NewCreditRules.com makes no guarantees of any kind. This web site may contain information that is created and maintained by a variety of sources both internal and external. These sites are unmoderated forums containing the personal opinions and other expressions of the persons who post the entries. NewCreditRules.com does not control, monitor or guarantee the information contained in these sites or information contained in links to other external web sites, and does not endorse any views expressed or products or services offered therein. In no event shall NewCreditRules.com be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any such content, goods, or services available on or through any such site or resource.

Popular Posts

  1. Credit CARD Act contains amendment inspired by this campaign

  2. Bankers Vow Revenge

  3. Republicans less likely than Democrats to have too much debt?

  4. Credit card bill won't outlaw redlining

  5. Create your own data mining strategy

  6. Top 25 subprime lenders behind the mortgage meltdown

  7. President Obama’s bad idea

  8. Bank of America gets a new chairman: my good friend

  9. Should the rich pay higher interest rates?

  10. Scam alert: Avoid debt relief and credit repair firms

  11. Do you know your medFICO score?

  12. Kevin, you're "LOOKING for discrimination"

  13. Woman denied credit due to blacklisted mortgage company: Bank of America

  14. Video of Maryland bill hearing against “blacklisting”

  15. A comprehensive list of "toxic" mortgage companies

  16. Speaking engagement brings a pleasant surprise

  17. Credit card securitization encourages fee-based profit model

  18. Everything bad about the credit card industry exposed

  19. The Credit CARD Act is great, but not strong enough

  20. Companies cancel cards of responsible customers

  21. What’s your credit score, President Obama?

  22. Fair Isaac Co. will no longer sell Experian-based credit scores

  23. Why merchants suffer just as much as consumers do (Part I)

  24. Big defeat for consumers, small victory for American Express

  25. American Express says it has changed its discriminatory policy, but don't be fooled

  26. What’s your horror story? Do you have praise for a company?

  27. Beware: These stores could harm your credit! (Part II)

  28. Beware: These stores could harm your credit! (Part I)

  29. Major banks cope with shame of being on welfare

  30. What affects your credit score


Great Resources

  1. ChangeInTerms.com

  2. Complaints.com

  3. ConsumerAffairs.com

  4. Consumerist.com

  5. CreditMattersBlog.com

  6. CreditSlips.org

  7. DefendYourDollars.org

  8. Epinions.com

  9. GotaClassAction.com

  10. My3Cents.com

  11. PlanetFeedback.com

  12. RipoffReport.com
* List provided by ChangeInTerms.com.


Selected Media Coverage



Powered by Johnson Media Inc. and consumers who want to make a difference.